Self-funders in England charged 40% more on average than councils pay, research finds
Research for Baroness Louise Casey's commission finds no one is clearly in charge of adult social care in England and, according to Nursing Times, that people who pay for their own care are charged on average 40% more than councils pay.
England has no one clearly in charge of social care
England is an international outlier in lacking any clear system of stewardship for social care, unlike France and Germany. That is the central finding of research commissioned by the Casey Commission and published on 11 November 2026 (opens in a new tab) by the Nuffield Trust and the Institute for Government.
The same research found that people who pay for their own care in England are charged on average 40% more (opens in a new tab) than councils pay for people whose care councils arrange, according to Nursing Times.
Taken together, the two findings point to a market formed by default rather than design. Commissioners are shaping that market now, providers depend on its fees, and the Casey Commission's recommendations are not due until summer 2027.
Casey: successive governments have left care unaddressed
Baroness Louise Casey, who chairs the independent commission reviewing adult social care in England, told the BBC's Today programme on 11 November 2026 that the sector has grown in a largely uncontrolled, unplanned way. She contrasted it with the deliberate design of the NHS in 1948.
Successive governments have left the issue unaddressed (opens in a new tab), Casey said. She described the care market as dominated by private providers, and the Care Quality Commission's oversight of it as watching from the sidelines rather than actively managing it.
Councils run very few of England's care home beds themselves, as the chart shows. They commission most of the care they arrange from a market that no national body steers.
Casey linked the findings to the Covid-19 Inquiry's Module 6 report, published in October 2026, which she said showed the consequences of the lack of stewardship. Prime Minister Andy Burnham told the Commons the inquiry had examined the pandemic's impact on publicly and privately funded adult social care (opens in a new tab) across all four UK nations.
Commissioning and markets · Care home places
Councils run just 2% of England's care home beds
Share of care home beds in England, by who runs the home · October 2026
About this chart
Note: Councils include the companies they own, as far as we have identified them (known data issue DI-003). A home registered twice is counted once.
Source: CQC register of care services, Baton calculation (opens in a new tab) Published 21 October 2026
Same condition, different care, depending on the postcode
Two people with the same condition can have very different experiences of care depending on where they live, the research found. Assessment processes, waiting times and levels of support all differ.
This is the other visible effect of having no clear steward. With no one setting consistent standards, each council area has built its own way of assessing and arranging care, and people feel the difference directly.
The 40% is a national average, not a local fee gap
The findings as reported do not break the 40% premium down by region, council area or type of care. A commissioner cannot read it as a fact about their own area, and a provider's own gap between self-funder and council rates may be wider or narrower.
What the figure does is put the gap on the record of the research behind the review. What self-funders pay compared with councils is now part of the reform debate, not a matter left to each local market.
No fix before summer 2027
The Casey Commission's full recommendations for structural reform of services for older people and adults with disabilities are not due until summer 2027.
The governance research is about who runs the system. Our earlier reporting covers what ministers plan to do on free personal care before Casey reports.
Until the Commission reports, the market that produces the self-funder fee gap stays as it formed: by default rather than design, with no one clearly in charge of it.
Part of the Casey Commission
Sources
-
01
Governments asleep at the wheel over social care, says head of review (opens in a new tab) BBC News Accessed 16 November 2026
-
02
Nuffield Trust and IfG expose weaknesses in social care governance in report commissioned by Baroness Casey (opens in a new tab) Nuffield Trust Accessed 16 November 2026
-
03
Casey accuses successive governments of lacking leadership on social care (opens in a new tab) Nursing Times Accessed 16 November 2026
-
04
Written statement: Covid-19 Inquiry: Module 6 Report (The Prime Minister (Andy Burnham)) (opens in a new tab) UK Parliament: Hansard Accessed 16 November 2026
Spotted an error? Email corrections@wearecare.co.uk
Baton. Care intelligence
Baton Care intelligence gathers care signals and source data, connects related evidence, checks claims against original sources, and turns them into the insights, charts and data we publish from. People set the editorial direction and produce every piece of content from what Baton holds. Everything is cleared in line with our editorial policy.
More in this topic
See moreBe the first to know
The week in UK social care, joined up and in your inbox. Less noise. Only what matters. Every Wednesday.
We’ll only use your email for the Care intelligence brief. You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy