CMA clears Welltower's 649-home deal after concerns in 30 local areas
The Competition and Markets Authority has cleared Welltower's purchase of 649 UK care home properties after Welltower and Apex Healthcare Properties agreed to sell or hand over homes to resolve competition concerns in 30 local areas of England and Scotland.
A 649-home deal ends with a few homes changing hands
Welltower bought 649 UK care home properties in October 2025 (opens in a new tab). To clear it with the competition regulator, it is selling or handing over the running of a small number of homes.
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) accepted the package on 10 September 2026 (opens in a new tab). That closes its first-stage inquiry without a full Phase 2 investigation.
The CMA acted only where it found a problem: 30 local areas across England and Scotland (opens in a new tab) where Welltower or one operator would hold a large share of nursing and residential homes for older people. Operators planning a deal and commissioners in those areas are the ones this changes.
The test is local overlap, not group size
Welltower is a US-based real estate investment trust. It took four portfolios previously owned and run by Barchester Healthcare, HC-One, Aria Care (including Asprey) and Danforth Care.
New operators took over day-to-day running as part of the deal, including Care UK and Apex Healthcare Properties, which operates via Barchester Healthcare. The CMA had no quarrel with the scale of that. It looked at each local area and asked whether one owner or operator would dominate it.
That is the lesson for any care group thinking about buying or selling. A national footprint of hundreds of homes passed. Too many homes in one place did not. Exposure has to be mapped area by area, because that is where the CMA looks.
Four buyers take the homes the CMA wanted out
The CMA's decision names the buyers. CGEN Care Group takes 5 homes, Healthcare Ireland takes 3 and the running of 4 more, while Care UK and The Orders of St John Care Trust take 1 each (opens in a new tab).
None of the sales completes until CQC, in England, or the Care Inspectorate, in Scotland, approves it. So no handover date has been set out, and commissioners with contracts at these homes face a change of provider on the regulator's timetable, not the buyer's.
The decision covers England and Scotland. Wales is not covered.
Are the new owners really independent of Welltower?
The CMA's consultation drew pointed concerns, The Carer reports (opens in a new tab): whether Care UK and Healthcare Ireland are independent of Welltower, what Healthcare Ireland's other acquisitions mean, and whether CGEN can manage homes spread across different areas.
The CMA concluded none of this changed its assessment. Commissioners in the affected areas will want to know who they are dealing with all the same.
Care UK already runs homes for Welltower and is now buying one of the homes Welltower had to let go. The CMA is satisfied. The decision does not say how that independence will be tested once the sales are done.
Worth checking
- Whether any home you operate near, or place residents in, sits in one of the 30 local areas the CMA identified in England and Scotland
- Whether homes in your area have moved to Care UK, The Orders of St John Care Trust, Healthcare Ireland or CGEN Care Group, and who now holds the CQC or Care Inspectorate registration
- For commissioners: that contracts, fee schedules and quality assurance arrangements have been formally novated to the new operator, with continuity of placements confirmed in writing
- For managers in neighbouring homes: your staff retention position, pay benchmarking and agency reliance, if a newly owned competitor starts recruiting locally
- Whether your own growth or disposal plans create a high share of homes in any single local area, which is the level at which the CMA's test bites
Sources
-
01
CMA Approves Care Home Disposals Following Welltower and Apex Investigation (opens in a new tab) The Carer Accessed 22 September 2026
-
02
CMA proposes to accept remedies in care home deal (opens in a new tab) Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) Accessed 22 September 2026
-
03
Commencement Notice (opens in a new tab) Competition and Markets Authority Accessed 22 September 2026
-
04
CMA Scrutiny of Care Home Mergers: Key Lessons from the Welltower Case (opens in a new tab) Knights plc Accessed 22 September 2026
-
05
Welltower / multiple care homes merger inquiries (opens in a new tab) Competition and Markets Authority Accessed 29 September 2026
-
06
Notice of consultation on undertakings in lieu (opens in a new tab) Competition and Markets Authority Accessed 29 September 2026
-
07
Decision on acceptance of undertakings in lieu of reference (opens in a new tab) Competition and Markets Authority Accessed 29 September 2026
Spotted an error? Email corrections@wearecare.co.uk
Baton. Care intelligence
Baton Care intelligence gathers care signals and source data, connects related evidence, checks claims against original sources, and turns them into the insights, charts and data we publish from. People set the editorial direction and produce every piece of content from what Baton holds. Everything is cleared in line with our editorial policy.
More in this topic
See moreBe the first to know
The week in UK social care, joined up and in your inbox. Less noise. Only what matters. Every Wednesday.
We’ll only use your email for the Care intelligence brief. You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy